Process Control at Polaroid
QM Assignment
Process Control at Polaroid
Professor : Rupesh Kumar Pati & Pof. Anand G By: Abhishek Ojha (EPGP - 04B - 003) Saurabh Kumar Singh (EPGP – 04B - 102) Toban Varghese (EPGP – 04B – 116)
Process Control at Polaroid
QM Assignment
Contents Polaroid Background..............................................2 Issues before the Project Green Light..................................3 Project Green Light................................................5 Control Chart Selection............................................5 Ishikawa Diagram to show efficacy of Greenlight Project..................12 Recommendations to further enhance quality..........................13 Attachments....................................................14
POLAROID BACKGROUND
Process Control at Polaroid
QM Assignment
Polaroid’s main line of business was instant photography. Edwin H. Land, Polaroid’s founder revolutionized photographic industry in 1948 with development of Polaroid camera. Since then, Polaroid had led the instant photography market. By mid-1970s, it offered two basic types of instant films viz. 1. Peel Apart 2. Integral.
Peel-apart film was based on older technology where user physically pulled the film from the camera, and then after a brief period, peeled apart the two sides of the film envelope to obtain the finished photograph. In integral film customers inserted a plastic cartridge containing ten frames. Top cover sheet was automatically ejected from the camera. By the mid-1980s most consumer instant film was integral. So there was a high demand for integral films. Due to large production of the films care was taken to meet the quality standards.
ISSUES BEFORE THE PROJECT GREEN LIGHT
Process Control at Polaroid
QM Assignment
Some of the shortcomings before the introduction of “Project Green Line” ( Endeavour to enhance quality in the product) are  Quality Control (QC) department at Polaroid had final responsibility
of release of films to the market. Process engineers at Polaroid were responsible for materials while mechanical engineers were responsible for the equipments. Because no one was responsible for the overall process of production, when defects were discovered much time was lost in blaming materials or machines.  The overall cost of defective products crossed more than $2M.  Each machinery ran on different parameters hence each reacted
uniquely to new parts, each ran at slightly different speed and each put products with different level of variations. These situations gave rise to low quality products.  QC used only perfect cameras for testing while most of the
customers had imperfect cameras. Hence QC was easily missing those issues where which were related to films and imperfect cameras.  Some people thought that QC was not testing issues which
customers do encounter.  Sampling process was imprecise and often inaccurate.  Act of testing was itself increasing the defect rate as whenever QC
auditors found a defective sample in a lot, they tested the larger sample from that lot and next lot.
Process Control at Polaroid
QM Assignment
PROJECT GREEN LIGHT Green Light, came from Murray’s original idea of having a light over the machines that would be green when they were running on target. As a part of green light it was needed to implement operator based statistical process control. The final plan consisted of three key elements.  First, Statistical process control principles would be adopted, as the
processes in control and capable of producing within specification would produce more with consistent quality.  Second, production operators would be given the process control
tools that the process engineering technicians has been using, and in conjugation with sampling would be expected to make deposition decision themselves.  Third quality control auditors would concentrate on training
operators and operationalizing specification one new products. There were two important aspects of the project which the project promoters had to sell to the higher management  Cost saving could be achieved through reduced sampling.  Due to reduced sample quality would not suffer.
CONTROL CHART SELECTION
Process Control at Polaroid
QM Assignment
Control chart for mean and standard deviation was selected to examine the process as range accounts only for the maximum and minimum sample values and is less effective than for large samples, where as sample standard deviation serves as a better measure of process variability. Minitab software is used to plot the various X bar s graphs. Operator’s measurement of machine is listed from 3rd August to 21st August. 3 different shifts are distinguished as A, B and C. Pod Weight Control And As per the graph for shift A pod weight performance variability is under control i.e. between UCL and LCL which means the process is under control. This indicated that the quality is good as the process is under control although the number of quality control sample is reduced. Please note that the X-bar chart, on top, shows the mean or average of each subgroup. It is used to analyze central location. The sigma chart, on the bottom, shows how the data is spread and used to study system
Process Control at Polaroid
QM Assignment
variability.
And As per the graph for shift B pod weight performance variability is under control i.e. between UCL and LCL which means the process is under
Process Control at Polaroid
QM Assignment
control. This indicated that the quality is good as the process is under control although the number of quality control sample is reduced.
Process Control at Polaroid
QM Assignment
And As per the graph for shift C pod weight performance variability is under control i.e. between UCL and LCL which means the process is under control. This indicated that the quality is good as the process is under control although the number of quality control sample is reduced. However the last three dates show decreasing trend. So Polaroid should investigate the cause before the process goes out of control.
Process Control at Polaroid
QM Assignment
Finger Height Control The control of Finger height in Shift A is out of control. Machine should be inspected, parameters at which machine is running should be reviewed and raw materials quality should be inspected as to find out why is the process going out of control. First two and last points are clearly our of control as they lie outside the UCL-LCL limit.
The control of Finger height in Shift B seems totally out of control. Machine should be inspected, parameters at which machine is running
Process Control at Polaroid
QM Assignment
should be reviewed and raw materials quality should be inspected as to find out why is the process going out of control. Almost all the points are out of control. This shift should be clearly inspected and changes should be brought in to control the process and thereby enhancing the quality.
Shift C seems to be in control as all the points are lying within the LCL and UCL limits and also no part of the graph is showing tendency to increase or decrease.
Process Control at Polaroid
QM Assignment
ISHIKAWA DIAGRAM TO SHOW EFFICACY OF GREENLIGHT PROJECT
Process Control at Polaroid
QM Assignment
RECOMMENDATIONS TO FURTHER ENHANCE QUALITY.  Investigating the root cause of the problem is mandatory. Most of
samples of Finger Height measurement are out of control (as
Process Control at Polaroid
QM Assignment
seen from above control charts). Polaroid should investigate the cause of this problem so they can prevent the same problem occurring in the future.  Polaroid should ensure that the operators should adhere to the
processes. They should keep themselves off from tweaking in the machinery and follow the standards. Standards will help in reducing variability thereby enhancing the quality.  Some of the defects such as imperfect camera of user and films
should also be reciprocated. Films should mention tolerance of imperfection so that any issue arising does not directly blame the quality of the films. Users should also maintain their camera imperfections.
ATTACHMENTS  GROUP_07_SEC_B_data.xls  GROUP_07_SEC_B_Chart
(This is mini tab project)

m 000100020003000400040005000600010007 0001 0005
0005m0001 0001
0003000e 0004 000f00100007 0002 0003 0011001200130013001400150016
m 000100020003 00040005 } 00060007 00020007
00030002 000e000f } 00100011 0012000200070013001400020015 001300030016 00040007 0016 000300020001 0014000400010012 001500020003 000300040005 0016000f
—0004 0003000e 0014 m0003 001700160015 0018000300160016000700010004 }
001900040005 001a001b001c001d } } } } }
001e 000300160005001300150016 001f 0015 0019000200040007 000200040007 ! 00040012000b0003 '0016 0003 000500130015 #0013000200010004 000e
$0013 0007 00040012000b0001000e 0003001600050013001500040007 00020012000b00010016 000700130012%00160003 m 000100020003 00040005 0002'0016 001200160002001300030016001200160007 000200070005 0001 0005
&m ' (0016000e 001600010016001200160007 m0003 00150016 00040007 0015 0007 0003 0001
) 0003 0005001300150016 0012 00030016 0015 00070004 00160007
#0013000200010004 000e } *000b001600030002 0003 00020012000b00010016 000200070005 00120002(0016 00050004 0004 0004 0007
00050016001500040004 0007 0016001200160001'0016 } 001f 0002001300050004 0003 0014 00150013 0007 000300020004000700040007 001600030002 0003 }
001e 0016 001e0002( 0014 m0003 001700160015 0018000300160016000700010004 }
*000b001600030002 0003
} } }
}
001f 0002001300050004 0003 }
}
00020012000b00010016 0004+ 001200160002001300030016001200160007 0003000200070005 00120001000e 00160003 00040014 , 00060014 0016 001200160002001300030016001200160007 0004 0013 0014 0001000400120004 0013 0005 -0007 0016
001200020015 000400070016 00060014 001c 0015 0007001600150013 0004'0016 001200160002001300030016001200160007 00040007 000500020007 00160003 . 00070016,
0013 0005 -0007 0016 001200020015 000400070016 000200010015001300010002 0016 0016 001200160002001300030016001200160007 0001000400120004 /0013 00160003 000200070005
0001 -001600030
0019000200040007 001600070002000700150016 }
001000160015000200010004%00030002 0016 0016 001200020015 000400070016
0012000b000200030004 0007 ¢ 00010005m 00010002000300040004 }
}
*000b001600030002 0003 001500020007
0015 00020007 0016 0016 000b001600160005
00160012000b00030002 0013000300161 000200070005
000b00030016001300030016 0014 0016
001200160015 000400070016 0019000200040007 001600070002000700150016 0002
001300070004#00130016 0016 0014 00010013 0004 0007
-0004 001600020015 001200020015 000400070016
! 000300030007 00170018 0019 00010002000300040004 }
}
*000b0016000300020003 0003 0002'0016
0013 0005 -0007 0016
001200160015 000400070016 0019000200040007 001600070002000700150016 0002
00050016 001600030012000400070016
000200070005000200030004.00160005 %0016
000b000300020015 000400150016 0003 001500160005001300030016
0014 0003 000200010001 0016 001200160015 000400070016
0010001600020015 0004 0007
0015 00020007 0016 0016 0015 000700150016 0014 - 0003(
00120002 00160005 00040007 0016 001600020005 0014 0016 - 0003(00160003
} —000200030005 } } } }
*000b001600030002 0003 00040007( 0002 0013 00040007 0005 -0007 0016
001200020015 000400070016 0004 0012 00030016 0016+000b001600070004'0016 0019000200040007 001600070002000700150016 00040007( 001600040003 0017 % 0004
%00130003001600020013001500030002 0004.00160005
001f 00160003 0007000700160001 0005 0007 00030013 0016 001600030002 0003 20007 0004000700160016000300040007 00160015 000700040015000400020007 0014001600160001 0002 0016000e 000200030016
%0016 00160003 00020007 0016 001600030002 0003000f
m& 3000700020001000e0004 0014 0003 m*4 500160004 67%00020003
001000020007 0016
0011000f8001b8 0011000f8001b001b
9000f9' 9000f9001d:
0011000f001c001a9 0011000f001c001a001b 0011000f001c98
9000f9001c001a 9000f98; 9000f9001b0011
0011000f8001b001d
9000f9001b001a
0011000f001c001a9 0011000f001c001a; 0011000f001c99 0011000f8001b'
9000f9:' 9000f9;9 9000f988 9000f001a9'
0011000f001c99
9000f989
<001e<
<
>001e<
= 0011000f880011 = 0011000f001c99 = 0011000f001c'8
m& 3000700020001000e0004 0014 0003 m*4 500160004 67$00020003 001000020007 0016 0011000f8001b; 9000f9' 0011000f8001b001b 9000f9001d: 0011000f001c001a9 9000f9001c001a 0011000f001c001a001b 9000f98; 0011000f001c98 9000f9001b0011 0011000f8001b001d 9000f001a001a001a 0011000f001c001a9 9000f9:' 0011000f001c001a; 9000f9; 0011000f001c99 9000f988 0011000f001c9' 9000f9001d'
<001e<
<
>001e<
= 9000f001a'001d = 9000f9:: = 9
} 001e00040016 0016 (0016000e 00050016001400160015 %00020015( 001a000f
0011000f
00020015 001300020001 0003 00150016
001200160002001300030016001200160007 m 0005 -00160004 = 001200160002001300030016 0014 0016 0005
0015 001200040007 00140014 0016 0005 001200020015 000400070016 ?00040007 00160003 -00160004 = 001900160002001300030016 00070001000e 00070016 00140003000200120016
0002 0016 000400120016 - 001300010005 %0016 0016001700160015 00160005
001a0014001b001c0005001d¢0002